Questions & Answers

Further elaboration about "comprehensive MIDI editing"

+9 votes
295 views
asked Aug 14, 2016 in Studio One Feature Requests by Korky (370 points)
I realise my initial question was somewhat generalised - I was wary of being too wordy!  The kind of editing I'm referring to can best be illustrated by a few hypothetical examples:

Example 1: I've recorded a piano performance, but there's one particular range of notes (let's say C5 - A5) that sounds unpleasant above a velocity of 110.  If any notes in that range exceeds 110, I want to reduce them (and only them) to exactly 110.  

Example 2: I have some sampled strings - their volume is controlled by MIDI CC7.  I've drawn a series of intricate CC7 controller curves to control their dynamics - its shape is just right.  Now I change my mind - I don't like those strings and change them for a different string library - but its dynamics are controlled by CC1, not CC7.  I want to transform the CC7 curve I spent ages getting right into CC1.

Example 3: I've programmed a marching snare rhythm.  The actual part is what I want, but the velocity range of what I've played is too wide.  I decide the best sounding velocity range of the snare is between 30 and 70.  I want to compress the recorded velocities, and centre the result around velocity 50.

These only a few examples of editing tasks that are very hard to do in Studio One, and some would appear to be impossible -but they're the kind of thing I do all the time. In Sonar (my current DAW) the above examples can all be done quickly with a handful of clicks using either the Interpolate feature or CAL scripts.

I know Sonar's way of doing things isn't everyone's cup of tea, but it is capable of doing most MIDI transform functions very easily.  So why don't I stick with Sonar, you may ask?  Because I love everything else about Studio One, and would jump ship happily if only I could do the same sort of MIDI manipulations that I can in Sonar.
related to an answer for: Comprehensive MIDI editing tools

1 Answer

+2 votes
answered Aug 15, 2016 by Funkybot (21,640 points)
Those are good examples. For #1 and #3, I suggested a MIDI Velocity Compressor/Scaler Note FX plugin in another thread here. Check it out and vote if you think it would be helpful: http://answers.presonus.com/8108/note-fx-velocity-scaler-compressor?show=8108#q8108

And I agree that it should be easier to swap MIDI CC's from one to another.
...