Question

When I quantize a Track, I expect the transients to be positioned to the next grid possible.
This is not what happens in Studio One.

Instead, I get a misplaced bend marker, long after the transient starts and in result a "quantized" track that plays too early.

Some pictures.
Take a close look at the grid on bar 14.2.

This is what I get:


This is what I expect:


This issue has been there for years apparently.

https://answers.presonus.com/9651/option-quantizing-from-beginning-transient-rather-than-end
https://forums.presonus.com/viewtopic.php?f=151&t=30445This issue has been there for years apparently.

It's extremely annoying. Please fix this.

Answer 1

Depends on how you quantize, beginning with grid vs. groove and then moving on to other parameters such as your selected quantize value.  Also, depending on how far off your original audio happens to be and where you think a transient should be vs. where S1 detects it to be, you may still need to use audio bending to get some transients where you want them. Here are some useful deep dives into quantizing both audio and MIDI in S1.